Compare The Best Mattresses 2018

Tired of searching for the right mattress? Spent too much time testing mattresses only to find they're not quite right?

Brand
Rating
Features
puffy icon

101 Night Sleep Trial

  • 100% Manufactured in the USA
  • CertiPUR-US Certified foam
  • Free shipping
  • Lifetime guarantee
Puffy Best Mattress
leesa icon

100 Night Sleep Trial

  • One mattress donated for every ten sold 
  • Made in the USA
  • Free shipping and returns
  • White glove delivery available
Ecosa Icon

100 Night Sleep Trial

  • Only waterproof, ergonomic mattress with adjustable firmness
  • Three-in-one adjustability: medium, medium-firm, firm
  • Built-in air circulation system and bed bug proof cover
  • 15 year limited warranty
  • Compatible With Any Base
Nuvanna icon

100 Night Sleep Trial

  • Great customer feedback
  • Reasonably priced
  • Cooling, motion control, and support layers
  • Free shipping
  • Full refund if not satisfied
loom & leaf icon

120 Night Sleep Trial

  • 15-year warranty, which is not voided by using a platform bed
  • Delivery includes full-service setup and free mattress removal
  • Multi-layer construction, including a cooling gel layer for a cool night’s sleep
  • Choose from two comfort levels, L&L Relaxed Firm and L&L Firm
  • Hand-crafted with eco-friendly foams in the USA
Saatva Icon

120 Night Sleep Trial

  • Beds manufactured to order
  • Free white glove delivery includes full installation
  • USA-made in 19 different factories
  • Eco-friendly foam, recycled steel, and organic cotton
  • Free mattress removal
Muse Icon

120 Night Sleep Trial

  • Free shipping and full refund policy
  • 10-year warranty
  • Diamond Breeze technology ensures a cool sleeping experience
  • Online mattress quiz to determine the best mattress for each individual
  • Affordable yet high-quality bedding products
zenhaven icon

120 Night Sleep Trial

  • Made with natural latex, organic New Zealand wool, and organic cotton
  • Hypoallergenic, resistant to mold and dust mites, and toxin-free
  • Free white glove delivery & mattress removal
  • Two firmness levels in the same mattress: Luxury Plush and Gentle Firm
  •  15-year warranty
Nectar Icon

365 Night Sleep Trial

  • Forever Warranty, for as long as you have the mattress
  • Free shipping and returns
  • Customer support 7 days a week
  • Lease-to-own financing plan
tomorrow sleep icon

365 Night Sleep Trial

  • Hybrid bed combines the features of memory foam and spring mattresses
  • 10-year warranty
  • Made in the USA by Serta Simmons Bedding
  • Free 2 to 3-day shipping in the contiguous United States
  • White Glove delivery service offered at an additional cost

Best Mattresses 2018

Tired of waking up every morning feeling stiff and sore? Are you tossing and turning all night? It might be time for a new mattress. These days it seems like there is an endless variety of choices. Memory foam, inner spring, hybrid, or latex...and that's just the beginning. What do all these things mean, and where do you even begin?

We know that mattress shopping can be an ordeal.  Everyone wants to sell their products. Salespeople are aggressive and happy to corner you with endless lists of features and benefits, without telling you any of the negatives. It's hard to find the truth if you're not an expert, and let's face it, most of us aren't.

Mattress

We only go mattress shopping a handful of times in our lives, but it is an extremely important decision. Remember, you are about to purchase something that you will be sleeping on every night for the next 7 - 10 years. You want to make sure you get something that is going to keep you comfortable and help you to sleep well.  

Here at Bed Tester, we are the objective voice or reason. We aren't trying to sell any particular type of mattress so we can give you the facts. Furthermore, we have done all the hard work for you. We looked high and low to find this years best mattresses. We've researched, studied, and compiled all of the data so that you can make an informed decision without ever having to leave the comfort of your home.


Why Do You Need A Good Mattress?

This may seem like a silly question, but many people don't realize just how important it is to have a good mattress, or all the health problems associated with having a bad one. The amount and quality of sleep that you get is a key factor in maintaining good health. With today's busy lifestyle it is not uncommon to be in bed for only 5 or 6 hours. Therefore, it is especially crucial that your sleep is of the absolute best quality, and the only way to get quality sleep is on a well built, comfortable mattress.

mattress

Lack of sleep and poor sleep quality have been proven to contribute to  low concentration, decreased driving ability, reduced productivity, high blood pressure, and heart disease, just to name a few. On the other hand, getting proper rest will improve your memory, help you to live longer, reduce inflammation, increase creativity, lower your stress levels, and help you maintain a healthy weight. Your sleep is also highly related to your mood levels and the way that you interact with other people. In short, good sleep or lack thereof affects almost every area of your life. As you can see, sleep very important. But how do you know if you need a new mattress?

Most mattresses these days last for about 7 - 10 years. Materials break down, fabrics stretch, and springs lose their elasticity. If you have a mattress in this age range it's probably time to start looking. Not that mattresses magically go bad when they reach 10 years of age. In fact, with modern technology some are able to last longer than 10 years. However, if you are waking up stiff and sore, or if you are restless through the night and feel unrested in the morning, there is a good chance you are in need of a new mattress no matter how old yours is. Even newer mattresses can cause you to sleep poorly if they are not good quality or if they aren't the right fit for you.

Finding The Best Mattress For You

There are a lot of things to think about when choosing a new mattress. Some of them are objective, like material quality, warranty length, and price, while others are purely a matter of personal preference, such as firmness or type of mattress. We will review a lot of these options with you and go into each of the main types in detail. We want you to be able to make an informed decision about which mattress is right for you. If you have trouble making up your mind, don't sweat it. It is not a life altering decision. All of our top mattress picks have long sleep trials and allow you to return your mattress at any point during this period so that you don't have to worry about making an expensive mistake and purchasing a mattress that just isn't right for you.

Types

The fasted way to narrow down your mattress selection is to decide on the type of mattress that you want. There are four main types available today, and they all have their own unique features. Which one is right for you is mostly a matter of personal preference. We will give you an overview of each type as well as an example of each that was special enough to make it onto our top 10 list.

Hybrid

Hybrid mattresses are made from a combination of materials, such as coils, memory foam, and latex. They are designed to provide you with the best features of each of the other types of mattresses. The latex is cooling, the memory foam provides great pressure relief and the coils provide the underlying support that you need. Hybrid mattresses are a very good option for the the majority of people. One example of an excellent hybrid mattress would be the Tomorrow Sleep mattress. 

Latex

Latex mattresses are made exclusively from latex foam. Latex is cooling and provides good comfort, bounce, and responsiveness. This is a good choice for those who want the comfort of a foam mattress, but don't want the body contouring or "hugging" feeling of a memory foam mattress. Zen Haven makes our favorite latex mattress.

Memory Foam

Memory foam mattresses have become very popular and are known for having great support, pressure relief, and body contouring. You may have heard that memory foam mattresses make you hot when you sleep, but new technology has made it possible to create memory foam that is very cooling while still maintaining it's other excellent properties. Some of our favorite memory foam mattresses are Loom & Leaf, Nectar, and Nuvanna.

Coils

Coil or innerspring mattress are the traditional mattress type, and are still one of the most widely used mattresses today. They are designed with one or more layers of inner coils that provide support and comfort. One thing to remember if you are shopping for a coil mattress is that, higher numbers of coils means better comfort and support. Saatva makes a great coil mattress that easily made it on our top 10 list.

Firmness

After deciding on the type of mattress you want, you are going to want to decide on your firmness level. Firmness is largely a matter of personal preference, however, you want a mattress that is going to support your body without putting any pressure on you. Mattress firmness is measured on a scale of 1 -10, with 1 being the softest and 10 being the most firm. The majority of people prefer a medium firmness level (around 5-7). Most of the mattress on our top ten list fall in this range, although several have different firmness options that you can choose from.

Materials

Mattresses today are made out of many different materials. Traditionally mattresses were made with Synthetic materials which tend to be more durable and last longer than natural materials. These days however, natural, plant-based, and organic materials are becoming more and more popular in mattress manufacturing. The choice is really up to you. Our top ten list offers many organic and natural options.

Motion Isolation

This feature might be important to you if you sleep with a partner, especially if that person tends to move around a lot throughout the night. A mattress with good motion isolation will make it so that you can hardly feel any movement on the other side of the mattress. Since this is such a common problem for couples, any newer high quality mattress is going to have very good motion isolation.

Value/Company Reputation

This is where we have done all the hard work for you. All of the mattresses on our top ten list are an excellent all around value. The companies that make them are reputable and stand behind their work. They all offer long seep trials and have excellent warranties. 

Best Mattresses In Detail

We showed you our top ten mattress picks for 2018, but we realize that you will probably need a little more info before you make your mattress purchase. Here we will give you all the juicy details you need about our favorite mattresses. 

Puffy Best Mattress
puffy icon

Most Comfortble Mattress

Our Rating

Puffy is quickly becoming known as the most comfortable mattress on the market. In fact, they were ranked the best mattress of 2018. Customers say it really is like sleeping on a cloud. Puffy is specially designed to cradle your body while still providing support. The patent pending Cooling Cloud top layer is made with a gel-infused Visco poly foam. It behaves like memory foam, but is 8 times more effective at maximizing airflow.  It pulls heat away from the body and keeps you cool while you sleep. The 7" bottom layer is made of Firm Core Support Foam using Insta-Firm technology which gives 99% more responsiveness and 4 times more support than a normal mattress. This allows you to place the mattress on any hard surface, and gives you the firmness you need while adjusting perfectly to the pressure points in your body. All of this fluffy goodness is wrapped in a zip-n-wash cover that is easy to take off and wash just like your bed sheets. Queens sell for $950 and come with a 101 night in-home sleep trial. Read Full Review >>>

Puffy Mattress
  • Pro​s
  • Cons
  • Great value for the money
  • Free shipping and returns, 101 night in-home sleep trial, limited lifetime warranty
  • check
    Can be used on any surface
  • check
    Handcrafted in the USA using environmentally friendly practices
  • check
    Puffy makes donations to children in need of beds
Puffy Mattress
tomorrow sleep icon

Best Hybrid Mattress

Our Rating

The Tomorrow Sleep Hybrid Mattress offers the best of both worlds. You get the pressure relieving comfort of a memory foam mattress with the unmatched support of individually wrapped coils. This mattress is made with the finest materials such as hypoallergenic foam and a NASA designed, cooling top layer. Tomorrow offers free shipping & returns, a 10 year Serta Simmons warranty, and a full 365 night in-home trial. At $940 for a Queen, we feel like the Tomorrow Hybrid mattress is a great value for the money. Bottom line.....you will sleep like a baby for years to come on this mattress.

Tomorrow sleep
  • Pro​s
  • Cons
  • Hypoallergenic CertiPUR-US® certified foam
  • Cooling Memory Foam and top coating created by NASA, helps regulate your body temperature in real-time
  • check
    Gel Swirl Memory Foam contours to your body for unbeatable pressure relief
  • check
    Pocketed Coils flex individually for advanced support with unrivaled motion-isolation
  • check
    Two feels to choose from, medium firm & medium soft
  • check
    Free shipping and returns, 365 night in-home trial, and 10 year Serta Simmons warranty
Tomorrow Sleep
Nectar Icon

Best Overall Value

Our Rating

Nectar makes a high quality memory foam mattress that provides a unique comfort experience. It is constructed of multiple foam layers with each having a different purpose. Some for support, some for weight distribution and comfort, and a cooling top layer to wick away heat. It is medium firm (about 6.5 out of 10) and you will notice almost no motion transfer when your partner moves. Nectar offers the industry's best return policy and has a lifetime warranty. All this combined with their $699 (Queen) price point makes Nectar our pick for best overall value.

Nectar Mattress
  • Pro​s
  • Cons
  • Tencel Cooling Cover helps to circulate air and wick away heat while you sleep
  • Dust mite and bed bug resistant
  • check
    365 night in-home trial with free shipping and returns, and Forever Warranty
  • check
    Adaptive Hi Core Memory Foam supports your body and provides critical rebound and bounce
  • check
    Gel memory foam distributes your weight evenly and offers cool contouring support
  • check
    Works with any bed type
  1. TENCEL COOLING COVER - Helps circulate air and wick away heat. It’s also bedbug resistant!

  2. QUILTED GEL MEMORY FOAM - Contours perfectly to your body while and increases air circulation.

  3. GEL MEMORY FOAM - Distributes your weight evenly, offering cool, contouring support.

  4. ADAPTIVE HI CORE MEMORY FOAM - Supports your body, providing crucial rebound and bounce.

  5. BREATHABLE BASE LAYER - Reinforces the contouring and support layers, giving you a stable, breathable foundation.

Nectar Mattress

Get $125 Off With Code: SHOP125

Plus 2 Free Pillows!

Saatva Icon

Best Innerspring Mattress

Our Rating

Saatva is one of the finest mattresses out there. While other companies were trying to compete in the foam bed market, Saatva took a different approach and set out to build the absolute best coil spring mattress on the market. In our opinion, they have succeeded. Their mattresses are built with a unique double layer coil system that provides ultimate support and minimal motion transfer. They added a layer of memory foam for pressure relief and topped it off with an organic cotton cover and euro pillow top. They also offer 3 different firmness levels, free white glove delivery, and 0% APR financing. Their luxury Queen is currently selling for $999. You can't go wrong with a Saatva luxury mattress. 

Saatva Mattress
  • Pro​s
  • Cons
  • High quality manufacturing on par with the best of the best
  • Saatva mattresses are available in three different firmness levels
  • check
    Movement is extremely well isolated, which means you wont feel your partner moving
  • check
    Constructed in the USA from the highest quality renewable and sustainable products available
  • check
    Saatva is America's best priced luxury mattress
  • check
    Free white glove delivery and old mattress removal, 120 day in-home trial, and 15 year warranty
Saatva Mattress
loom & leaf icon

Best Luxury Memory Foam Mattress

Our Rating

Loom & Leaf is an ultra luxury memory foam mattress, made of high quality, durable components. It is also a healthy, green memory foam mattrress, built from eco-friendly foams that are sourced in the USA. This mattress comes in relaxed firm, and firm options, and is especially ideal for side sleepers. There is little to no motion transfer with this mattress and the cooling gel panel and convoluted pockets make this a great choice for hot sleepers. It is comparable to a mid-range Tempur-Pedic but is only a fraction of the cost. Their queen sells for $1099, and comes with free white glove delivery, free mattress removal, a 120 night in-home trail, and a 15 year warranty. This mattress has received over 25,000 five star reviews.

Loom & Leaf Mattress
  • Pro​s
  • Cons
  • Made with dense, plant-based foams, and organic non-toxic components
  • Loom & Leaf uses bio foams and laminated gel foam layers to deliver the coolest mattress out there
  • check
    You can choose between two different comfort levels
  • check
    Handcrafted in the USA
  • check
    Free white glove delivery and mattress removal, 120 night in-home trial, and 15 year warranty
Loom & Leaf Mattress
Quilted Organic Covering
Dual Layer Breathable Support
Cooling Spinal Gel
Eco-Friendly, 5lb Premium Foam
Muse Icon

Best Performance Mattress

Our Rating

Muse is our top choice for performance mattress. Performance mattresses are designed to take your sleep to the next level, and they must incorporate a new technology or construction. Muse meets this qualification with their new Cold Wire Cover, which uses specialized Cold Wire yarns to create a phase-changing material that is cool to the touch. It also helps to evenly distribute your weight across the bed, giving one of the coolest most comfortable sleep experiences on the market today.

Muse offers three different firmness levels which is more than most other memory foam manufacturers. There is very little motion transfer with this mattress and it is constructed using high quality materials and craftsmanship. The Queen is a steal at $950 and all sizes come with a waterproof coating that preserves and protects your mattress.

Muse Mattress
  • Pro​s
  • Cons
  • Great prices
  • Supportive, comfortable, and cool
  • check
    Made in the USA
  • check
    Removable cover for easy cleaning
  • check
    Free shipping and returns, 120 night in - home sleep trial, 10 year warranty
Muse Mattress

Get $100 Off With Code: SLEEP

zenhaven icon

Best Latex Mattress

Our Rating

Zenhaven is an ultra luxury, totally natural latex mattress that competes with the very top luxury brands in the industry.  Their material choice and construction quality is top notch which allows them to offer a 20 year warranty. This mattress is also flippable which gives you two different firmness options in the same mattress, a unique feature in our top ten list!

Latex offers the pressure relief and body contouring of a memory foam mattress without giving you that "hugging" or sinking in feeling. Motion isolation is not quite on the same level as the top of the line memory foam mattresses, but is still very good. Furthermore, Zenhaven uses a proprietary 5-zone latex comfort layer that gives great support and provides a cool and comfortable sleep. Their Queen sells for $1899 and comes with free delivery, set-up, and old mattress removal. If you are looking for a top of the line mattress that will last and is also natural, there is no better choice than Zenhaven.

Zenhaven mattress
  • Pro​s
  • Cons
  • Not best for someone on a budget
  • Exclamation Triangle
    It's very heavy if you would ever need to move it
Zenhaven Mattress
Ecosa Icon

Best Adjustable Mattress

Our Rating

Ecosa is the only mattress on our top ten list that offers 3 adjustable firmness levels. This is a versatile feature that is very handy as sleeping needs often change over the years. Ecosa is one of the firmer models on our list and is great for back and stomach sleepers. It is made of high quality foams that are designed to last. It is also waterproof, bed bug, and dust mite resistant; features that often come only in much more expensive mattresses. Motion isolation is great, and Ecosa uses a built in air circulation system to keep you cool and let your mattress breathe. This mattress is designed for perfect spine alignment, and can be great for people with back problems. It can be used on any base, including the floor. At $999 for a queen, it is an exceptional value for the money. Read Full Review >>>

Ecosa Mattress
  • Pro​s
  • Cons
  • Our only top pick that offers 3 firmness levels in one mattress
  • Great for hotter climates because it sleeps so cool
  • check
    This mattress has a liner that is waterproof and bed bug resistant, which is nice
  • check
    Machine washable outer cover
  • check
    Free shipping and returns, 100 night in-home trial, and 15 year warranty
Ecosa Mattress

Get $100 Dollars Off Now!

Nuvanna icon

Best Mattress For An Active Lifestyle

Our Rating

Nuvanna is a strong up and comer in the online mattress market. Founded by a material scientist with decades of experience, he has developed an innovative new technology that will revolutionize the way you sleep. It's 3 layers are designed for cooling, motion control, and support, and Nuvanna is a great choice for active people looking to boost their recovery time. The cooling layer uses special phase-changing gel particles that disperse heat to keep you cool. Motion isolation is fantastic, so you won't be interrupted in your sleep, and Nuvanna's Progressive Support System, prevents that sinking feeling which can be common in memory foam mattresses. This layer also promotes proper spine alignment which relieves back pain. Nuvanna is compatible with all bed types and $890 for a queen is a great price for a great mattress. Read Full Review >>>

Nuvanna Mattress
  • Pro​s
  • Cons
  • Great value for the money
  • Innovative and unique technology
  • check
    Lightweight and easy to move
  • check
    Free shipping, 100 night in-home trial, and 10 year warranty
  • check
    If you don't love it, they will pick it up and donate it to The Salvation Army or another charity
Nuvanna Mattress

Get 10% Off With Code: SUMRBED10

leesa icon

Best Mattress For The Average Sleeper

Our Rating

Leesa wins the award for being the perfect mattress for the "average sleeper". It offers a great balance of comfort, support, cooling technology and motion isolation. It's proprietary Aveno foam is designed to promote airflow and does an excellent job of keeping you cool. The pressure relieving memory foam underneath is one of the more responsive materials on the market and gives the mattress it's universal feel which makes it loved by so many people. Finally, a 6" base foam layer provides the support you need without feeling too firm. The Queen sells for $995 which is a great price for a top-notch mattress.

Leesa Mattress
  • Pro​s
  • Cons
  • Leesa donates one mattress for every ten sold
  • Sleeps cooler than most other foam mattresses
  • check
    Relatively light and easy to move
  • check
    Most comfortable mattress for the widest variety of sleepers
  • check
    Made in the USA, free shipping and returns, 100 night in-home trial, 10 year warranty 
Leesa Mattress
Leesa Layer

1. Cooling Avena Foam

The 2" Avena® foam top layer provides airflow for a cooler night's sleep and enough bounce for freedom of movement.

Leesa Layer

2. Pressure Relieving Memory Foam

The 2" memory foam layer delivers the body contouring and pressure relief you've come to expect from memory foam.

Leesa Layer

3. Dense Core Support

The 6" base foam layer adds strength, durability and structure to support sleepers of all sizes, without feeling too firm.


Get $125 Off With Code: FRIENDS125

Copyright 2018 by Conklin Web Properties LLC. Privacy Policy.

Bed Tester
Login/Register access is temporary disabled