A quick note: we review products independently, but we may receive affiliate commissions when purchases are made through the links on our site.
These days, it seems as there’s a new memory foam mattress company springing up each day. Each company promises the best night sleep possible, but how many actually deliver on those claims?
Surprisingly enough, many of them do. These days, it’s more challenging than ever to narrow the field and select the best mattress for your needs because there are just so many solid mattress options on the market.
Let's explore Ecosa vs. Puffy in this brand comparison. We'll present all of Ecosa's mattress and other bedroom products alongside all of Puffy's mattress, bed frame and accessories options in our Ecosa vs. Puffy review, focusing especially on the companies' celebrated mattresses.
The Ecosa Mattress
The Puffy Mattress and The Puffy Lux Mattress
Price for Queen
$1,150 (The Puffy Mattress), $1,795 (The Puffy Lux Mattress)
$300 off queens
Ecosa is the maker of The Ecosa Mattress and The Ecosa Pillow. Ecosa has north of 10,000 reviews on the company's website. Eighty-six percent of Ecosa reviews come in at 5 stars, with 4-star reviews comprising 13 percent of reviews.
Puffy manufactures The Puffy Mattress and The Puffy Lux Mattress as well as the Puffy Adjustable Base, Puffy Bed Frame and Puffy Foundation. Puffy is creating a full-fledged bedroom company, with it also offering the Puffy Comforter, Puffy Pillow, Puffy Mattress Pad, Puffy Topper and Puffy Protector. Puffy's website sports almost 5,500 reviews for its various products.
It’s safe to say that Ecosa's mattress and Puffy's mattresses are exceptionally popular among the companies' customers.
Materials & Durability
Arguably the most important thing to consider when purchasing a new mattress is its durability and the materials from which it’s made.
Ecosa and Puffy offer similar mattresses in the sense that each mattress features three different layers of foam, as well as a removable and washable cover.
First, let’s take a close look at The Ecosa Mattress. This 9.5-inch mattress starts with a 6.5-inch layer of ergonomic support foam. This is the base layer of the mattress, and it features specially designed airflow cutouts to help you sleep cooler and more comfortably. This layer is designed to eliminate pressure points and keep your spine aligned as you sleep.
Next comes the 1.5-inch Eco-Tex memory foam layer, which is a medium-density open-cell foam that behaves similarly to latex. If you’ve ever slept on a latex mattress, you know that they’re extremely comfortable but sleep hot. Thankfully, the Eco-Tex layer provides the same level of comfort without the heat.
On top, you’ll find a layer of 1.5-inch G–7 Memory Foam that’s infused with cooling gel particles to help you stay cool and comfortable in bed.
The Ecosa Mattress, whose firmness is rated a 6 to 8, with 10 being very firm, comes with two covers. The outer cover is a zippable polyester cover. This cover is machine washable. The inner cover is resistant to dust mites, bed bugs and waterproof. All this protection saves you money from having to purchase a separate mattress protector to extend the life of your investment.
As for durability, customers of The Ecosa Mattress seem thrilled with the level of durability they receive from their mattress. Ecosa stands behind The Ecosa Mattress by offering a 15-year warranty. Many mattress companies offer only 10-year warranties, so this is something to consider if you're looking to get more mileage out of an expensive mattress.
The Puffy Mattress features a fairly similar configuration to The Ecosa Mattress. This mattress starts with a base layer of polyurethane foam that’s designed to provide firm support and a comfortable night’s sleep.
The Puffy Mattress is a 10-inch medium-firm mattress that the company rates at 6 to 8 in firmness, with 10 being the firmest. This mattress that starts with a 6-inch Firm Core Support base layer. This layer is topped with the 2-inch ClimateComfort layer. This is a temperature-stabilizing layer that is designed to head off temperature swings that can disrupt a comfortable night's sleep. You'll notice a gentle warming effect during the cold months and a cooling effect during the warm months.
The Puffy Mattress is topped with another 2-inch layer: the Cooling Cloud Foam layer. This top layer, made from visco-polyurethane foam, is infused with gel to help you maintain your temperature throughout the night.
The Puffy Lux Mattress is a 12-inch mattress with a bit more give. The company rates it a 5 to 7 in firmness and describes it as "medium-plushness." In this mattress, three out of four of the layers are identical with The Puffy Mattress, although the Firm Core Support base layer measures in at 7 inches. The Cooling Cloud top layer is 1.5 inches in this model and comes with a companion: the 1.5-inch Plush Dual Cloud layer.
The Puffy Lux Mattress is designed to offer additional support and contouring as well as enhanced spinal alignment.
Both Puffy mattresses comes with a stain-resistant cover that is Oeko-Tex Standard 100 Certified.
Considering Puffy's high ratings and lifetime mattress warranties, customers are finding that their Puffy mattresses are holding up well, with regard to durability. This said, sleepers weighing in excess of 230 pounds might find their mattresses are subject to breakdown faster because the company's foams are less dense compared with some competitors' foams.
One of the most important aspects to consider when it comes to any new mattress is how well the mattress cradles your body as you sleep. How well your mattress contours to your body can mean the difference between a great night’s sleep and waking up in the morning feeling like a zombie.
With three different foams at work, The Ecosa Mattress does an incredible job of cradling your body and providing an excellent and memorable sleep experience. Both memory foam layers do an exceptional job of cradling your pressure points, providing a weightless feel as soon as you lay on this mattress.
Each layer works in concert to provide independent support for your entire body, and these breathable layers, along with a breathable cover, make for a mattress that excels at contouring to the natural shape of your body. It's worth highlighting that more than 70 percent of Ecosa users found improvement with their back problems.
A striking feature about The Ecosa Mattress is its innovative adjustable firmness levels. Unlike other mattresses, which are available with a single firmness level, the Ecosa mattress can be adjusted to suit your personal taste. You can simply move the layers around to find the firmness level that meets your needs.
Not only does this functionality ensure that everyone is able to find comfort with an Ecosa mattress but it allows you to adjust the mattress as your needs change. Five or 10 years down the line, maybe you’ll have some new aches and pains to deal with or perhaps you’ll have gained or lost some weight. You’ll be able to adjust your Ecosa mattress to meet your changing needs.
The Ecosa Mattress is also touted for serving heavyweight sleepers well. The company claims The Ecosa Mattress can support up to 880 pounds, with a 440-pound limit on each side.
With so many similarities in construction, you may expect that The Puffy Mattress and The Puffy Lux Mattress also do a phenomenal job of contouring to your body. They certainly do.
With a standard memory foam layer and gel layer, each layer of The Puffy Mattress and The Puffy Lux Mattress work overtime to provide effective relief of your pressure points, providing the cradling that you need to have a great night’s sleep.
With its mattresses, Puffy also does an exceptional job of eliminating motion transfer, so you won’t feel your partner’s motion or any other disturbances in the middle of the night.
The Puffy Mattress and The Puffy Lux Mattress offer tremendous support for lightweight and average-size back sleepers, side sleepers and stomach sleepers. Heavyweight sleepers, however, might find Puffy's soft foams to provide less-than-adequate support.
Shipping and Trial Period
When it comes to buying a mattress online, customers are often wary of buying something so important without being able to try it out. Thankfully, most manufacturers offer free trial periods to allow customers to decide if they like the mattress enough to keep it, including Puffy and Ecosa.
Ecosa offers a generous 100-day in-home trial period so you can decide if The Ecosa Mattress is right for you. If you decide that the mattress isn’t a good fit, Ecosa will pick it up from your home and donate your slightly used mattress to a local Salvation Army.
In addition to the generous trial period, shipping is also free.
Similar to Ecosa, Puffy offers a fantastic trial period. You’ll be able to spend 101 days with your new mattress to decide if it’s the best mattress for you. If you decide the mattress isn’t a good fit, customer service will get your return started, and you’ll receive a full refund. As with Ecosa, shipping is also free.
Other Important Considerations
So far, it’s been hard to call in a winner when it comes to the Puffy vs. Ecosa mattress because they have so many similarities. Each mattress is exceptionally well made from top-quality materials, and as you’ll find when reading other Puffy mattress reviews or Ecosa mattress reviews, both are exceptionally popular among their customers.
Thankfully, there are a few areas where these mattresses differ which may help you make your decision more easily.
There are a few unique aspects about Ecosa and its mattress that you may want to consider more closely. Perhaps the most notable aspect is The Ecosa Mattress' innovative adjustable firmness levels. Ecosa accomplishes this by keeping each layer of their mattress separate, instead of fusing them altogether during construction. The different foam layers can be reconfigured to provide a mattress that’s more or less firm.
Although we love this innovative feature, an unfortunate caveat is that, because each layer has different properties, your configuration may affect how well the mattress manages your temperature or contours to your body.
Ecosa is based in Australia, but its mattresses are made in China from materials imported from Germany, Japan, and China. All materials are CertiPUR-US certified.
There are also a few aspects of Puffy's mattresses that make them unique. For one, Puffy does some great work with children’s charities through a unique program the company runs that is actually driven by their customers. For every 10 customers who post a photo of themselves enjoying their Puffy mattress and tag the company, Puffy donates a mattress to a child in need.
Puffy mattresses are made in the United States from domestically sourced materials, and the company also provides an industry-leading warranty on their mattresses. Although many companies cap their warranties at 10, 15 or 20 years, Puffy provides a lifetime warranty.
So if you’re looking for an American-made mattress that offers the peace of mind of a lifetime warranty, this may be enough to sway you toward a Puffy mattress.